Successfully Added

The product is added to your quote.

2 Year Warranty on ALL products

Head-to-Head: PowerFlex 40 vs. PowerFlex 40P – Which One is Right for You?

by Bryan Hellman
Head-to-Head: PowerFlex 40 vs. PowerFlex 40P – Which One is Right for You?

 

The Allen-Bradley PowerFlex drives from Rockwell Automation are widely used in industrial automation for reliable and efficient motor control. The PowerFlex 40 and PowerFlex 40P series stand out as compact, cost-effective solutions.

But which one is right for your needs? In this head-to-head comparison, we’ll break down their key features, control capabilities, I/O configurations, and ideal applications, helping you make an informed decision.

Quick Comparison Table: PowerFlex 40 vs. PowerFlex 40P

Before diving into the details, here’s a quick side-by-side comparison of the two drives. This table highlights their core differences, making it easier to identify which one aligns best with your requirements.

Feature PowerFlex 40 PowerFlex 40P
Voltage Range 100-120V, 200-240V, 380-480V, 500-600V 200-240V, 380-480V, 500-600V (No 100-120V option)
Horsepower (HP) 0.5 - 15 HP 0.5 - 15 HP
Control Modes Open-loop control (V/Hz, PID, Sensorless Vector) Open & Closed-loop (V/Hz, PID, Sensorless Vector, Incremental Encoder Feedback)
Speed Regulation 60:1 ratio 80:1 ratio (better precision)
I/O Terminals 4 programmable + 3 fixed digital inputs 5 programmable + 2 semi-programmable digital inputs
Communication RS-485, optional EtherNet/IP, DeviceNet RS-485, requires external controller for RTU Master role
HMI Interface Optional local keypad Integrated display + reset button
Safety Features Requires external safety modules Built-in Safe Torque-Off (STO) (SIL 2, PL d, Category 3 certified)
Mounting Options Panel & DIN rail (A & B-frame) Panel & DIN rail (B-frame only)
Best For General motor control (fans, conveyors, pumps) Precision control (material handling, packaging, fiber-spinning)

Which One Should You Choose?

Now that we’ve compared the key aspects, let’s summarize which drive suits different needs. Your choice depends on your application’s complexity, precision, and safety requirements.

✔ Choose PowerFlex 40 if:

  • You need a cost-effective drive for basic applications like pumps, conveyors, and fans.
  • You don’t require position control or precise speed adjustments.
  • You want simpler network integration with RS-485 and standard communication modules.

✔ Choose PowerFlex 40P if:

  • You need closed-loop control with precise speed and position feedback.
  • You require built-in Safe Torque-Off (STO) for safety compliance.
  • You work with applications like packaging, material handling, or fiber-spinning where precision matters.

1. Electrical Specifications

Understanding the voltage and power ratings is crucial when selecting the right drive. These factors determine whether a drive is suitable for your available power source and intended load.

  • PowerFlex 40 supports 100-120V, making it more versatile for low-voltage applications.
  • PowerFlex 40P lacks a 100-120V option but retains the same horsepower range (0.5-15 HP).
  • Both support single-phase operation, but PowerFlex 40P requires a 65% derating when used in single-phase applications.

2. Control Modes & Performance

The type of control mode a drive supports influences how precisely you can regulate speed and torque. Open-loop control is simpler, while closed-loop control enables greater accuracy and feedback-based adjustments.

  • PowerFlex 40 supports open-loop control with Sensorless Vector, V/Hz, and PID—suitable for applications that don’t require feedback.
  • PowerFlex 40P adds closed-loop control, allowing for precise speed regulation and basic position control using Incremental Encoder Feedback and Pulse Train Input.
  • PowerFlex 40P also has an 80:1 speed regulation ratio, making it more accurate than PowerFlex 40’s 60:1 ratio.

3. I/O Configuration & Connectivity

Input and output (I/O) terminals enable communication with external sensors, controllers, and actuators. More I/O options provide greater flexibility in complex automation setups.

  • PowerFlex 40 provides 4 programmable digital inputs + 3 fixed inputs.
  • PowerFlex 40P offers 5 programmable + 2 semi-programmable digital inputs, giving more customization flexibility.
  • PowerFlex 40P includes an additional programmable Form C relay output, which adds more customization for signaling.
  • Both drives support RS-485 communication, but PowerFlex 40P requires an external RTU Master for proper network integration.

4. HMI & Programming Ease

A drive’s Human Machine Interface (HMI) affects how easily operators can program, control, and monitor the system. The right interface can reduce setup time and improve usability.

  • PowerFlex 40P has an enhanced HMI with an integral display & reset button.
  • PowerFlex 40 requires an optional keypad for local control.
  • Both feature a CopyCat function, allowing quick duplication of drive configurations.

5. Safety Features

In industrial environments, safety is paramount. Drives with built-in safety features reduce the need for external components and provide better protection for equipment and personnel.

  • PowerFlex 40P includes Safe Torque-Off (STO), certified to SIL 2, PL d, and Category 3 standards—ideal for applications requiring high safety compliance.
  • PowerFlex 40 lacks built-in STO, requiring external safety modules.

6. Mounting & Environmental Features

How and where a drive is mounted affects installation flexibility and long-term durability. Additionally, environmental ratings determine resistance to dust, moisture, and extreme temperatures.

  • Both support panel & DIN rail mounting.
  • PowerFlex 40 extends DIN rail mounting to A-frames, making it more flexible in compact installations.
  • PowerFlex 40P supports IP66/NEMA/UL Type 4X/12 enclosures, providing better protection in harsh environments.

Which One Should You Choose?

Now that we’ve compared the key aspects, let’s summarize which drive suits different needs. Your choice depends on your application’s complexity, precision, and safety requirements.

✔ Choose PowerFlex 40 if:

  • You need a cost-effective drive for basic applications like pumps, conveyors, and fans.
  • You don’t require position control or precise speed adjustments.
  • You want simpler network integration with RS-485 and standard communication modules.

✔ Choose PowerFlex 40P if:

  • You need closed-loop control with precise speed and position feedback.
  • You require built-in Safe Torque-Off (STO) for safety compliance.
  • You work with applications like packaging, material handling, or fiber-spinning where precision matters.

Shop PowerFlex Drives & Elevate Your Automation

Selecting the right motor drive is essential for efficient industrial automation. We offer PowerFlex 40 and PowerFlex 40P drives, along with PLCs, motors, and automation accessories to optimize your system.

🔹 Need expert advice? Our specialists can help you select the right drive for your needs.
📞 Call us today or 📩 email us to get your PowerFlex drive delivered fast!

🚀 Shop Now: PowerFlex 40 Series | PowerFlex 40P Series

Back to Industrial Automation Co. Blog